Showing posts with label 2010 Book Review. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 2010 Book Review. Show all posts

Sunday, September 19, 2010

Lady in Waiting: My Review

Lady in Waiting: A Novel

It is said that those who do not know history are doomed to repeat it.  While I'm sure there is some truth to the statement, I have to wonder how much of history we are doomed to repeat simply because of our humanity?  While our fashions, governments and customs change through the years, the basics of humanity remain very much the same.  

Susan Meissner's books, including Lady in Waiting: A Novel link the past and the present through some artifact.  In this case, the artifact is a ring found in an old book.  It has the name "Jane" engraved inside it, and "Jane" is the lady who found it.  The modern-day Jane lives in Manhattan.  Her son just left for college and her husband just left her, saying they needed a break from each other to decide what they wanted in the future.  She is a woman who has always been a pleaser, making the choices she made because others wanted her to make them.  The historical Jane is Lady Jane Grey who ruled as Queen of England for 9 days.  Her story is told by her seamstress, Lucy.  Jane's path it seems is directed by others, primarily her parents, and her life is ended by an executioner--but at the end she has a choice to make, and revels in being able to make it.

I'm sometimes leery about reading books classified as Christian fiction if they are set during the Reformation.  All too often the Catholic Church ends up being the villain, the awful group trying to keep the truth from the masses.  Since I had read and enjoyed Meissner's books in the past, I decided to give this one a try, and I'm glad I did. 

 For those not familiar with Tudor England, Henry VIII (the guy with all the wives) broke from Rome and established the Church of England.  He left three children when he died:  Edward, who was raised Protestant; Mary who was raised Catholic and Elizabeth who was raised Protestant.  When he died, Edward became king, but was still a boy.  Edward died before he married.  The powers behind the throne did not want a Catholic ruler, so they got Edward to write a will passing the throne to his cousin, Jane, a Protestant.  Mary's supporters rallied and she was able to take power.  She had Jane and her supporters convicted of treason and executed.  Wikipedia calls Jane a Protestant martyr and the book states that Mary sent her confessor to try to obtain Jane's conversion (though whether it would have made any difference in her lifespan will never be known).  

While Lady in Waiting: A Novel talks about Jane writing to the Reformers on the Continent, the content of those letters is not discussed; religious references in the book are few and if the publisher wasn't a publisher of Christian fiction, I'd classify the book as historical fiction, not Christian fiction.  Though it mentions Jane being a Protestant and refusing to convert to Catholicism when Mary tried to get her to do so, I'd never know what either faith was about by reading this book.  In a lot of ways, this book confirms my personal opinion that the Reformation, for most people, particularly in England, was a lot more about politics than about religion. 

In short though, this is a wonderful novel that tells the story of two women who lived hundreds of years apart; two women whose lives seemed to be directed by other others; two women who realize that they can make choices.  It is well-written and is a title I'd recommend to those who say they don't like Christian fiction.

Saturday, September 18, 2010

The King's Christmas List by Eldon Johnson, Illustrated by Bonnie Leick

The King's Christmas List
What do you get a King for Christmas?  That is the question Emma and her dog Shu-Shu have to answer in The King's Christmas List.  One day, not long before Christmas they were decorating her playhouse for Christmas when the mailbox began to shine like a star.  Emma looked inside and found an invitation to the King's (King is always capitalized in this book) birthday party, His Christmas celebration.  Upon arrival of the invitation, things changed; Emma was now able to talk to and understand Shu-Shu.  


Having been invited to a birthday party, Emma's first question was what to take as a gift.  She decides to take a Christmas cake that she and her mother just baked, even though it is her favorite.  She puts on her Christmas cloak, grabs the cake and her favorite bear and she and Shu-Shu get into the carriage sent by the King.  On the way to the castle they meet a boy and he grandmother.  The boy is under-dressed and the  grandmother says he is cold. Emma gives him her cloak, and, since he looks hungry, the cake.  Next they meet a little girl and her  parents.  They appear to be poor and the little girl is crying because her teddy bear fell in the river and was gone.  Emma wonders if that is the only toy the girl had, and decides that, even as much as she loves Cherry Bear and goes nowhere without him, that this little girl needed him more.

When she gets to the party Emma notices that the guests are exchanging gifts but that no one is giving gifts to the King.  She asks why and He shows her that the people she met on the road were actually angels, sent to see if she had the real spirit of Christmas.  The King told her that by doing for others, particularly those in need, you give a gift to Him.

The pictures of the King are kind of "Jesus-ish", guy with long hair and a beard, wearing a long white robe and a small crown on His head.  My six year  old figured out quickly who the King was.  She enjoyed the story and has been trying to take it from me as I'm writing this review.  I found the story to be a charming rendition of "Whatsoever you do".  While set a Christmas, it could be used year-round.  However, while you can lead a horse to water, you can't necessarily make them give treasures away.  My daughter's "security blanket" is my old nursing pj shirt.  She adopted it even before I quit wearing it, and after it was obvious that it was her choice of objects, it became hers.  It is a rag, but to her it is a treasure.  I asked if she'd give "Shirtie" to someone who lost a toy, and she looked horrified.  Luckily, I'm sure  no one would want it.

I received this book free from the publisher through the BookSneeze.com book review bloggers program. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255 : “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”

Wednesday, September 15, 2010

The Way to a Man's Heart by Mary Ellis

The Way to a Man's Heart (The Miller Family Series)
The Way to a Man's Heart (The Miller Family Series) is a sweet predictable, rather religious  Amish romance.  Leah is eighteen years old and loves to bake.  One day she sees that an abandoned rail car being renovated into a diner.  She meets the owner who offers her a job as a cook/waitress.  It isn't long before the owner offers her the chance to invest in the business and she does.  The results are predictable.


In a lot of ways this is more of a coming of age book than a romance.  Yes, there is a romance, but the book is as much about Leah learning (the hard way) what it means to be an adult.  

While most Amish novels are classified as Christian fiction, they vary in how much religion they portray.  This one is on the heavy side with scripture quotes and a character who has lost his faith.  

Overall, I'd classify the book as mediocre, not terribly bad, but not all that great either.  Grade:  C+

I'd like to thank Christian Review of Books for my review copy.  Check out their website for reviews of all sorts of Christian books.  

Monday, September 13, 2010

A Christmas Prayer by Amy Parker, Illustrated by Marijan Ramljak

A Christmas Prayer

A Christmas Prayer is a charming board book that tells about the characters in the Christmas story via the prayer of a small child. It opens with the family, including two little ones, gathered around the tree. The child's Christmas prayer is one of thanks, not for toys and dolls. First, he gives thanks for his family, and then, on succeeding spreads, for Gabriel, Mary, Joseph, the donkey, the manger, the shepherds, the star, and then, for the perfect Christmas gift, Jesus. As the child thanks God for each of these gifts, a toy is added to the sofa. The final words are 

                            God, I know that Christmas 
                            Is more than toys or lists.
                            Thank You for loving me so much
                            And for these Christmas gifts.

My first grader and I read this tonight for our bedtime story and she enjoyed it.  I liked the fact that the Annunciation got mentioned; it isn't always in non-Catholic children's Christmas stories.  The child figures are cute and the way they are drawn, I don't really think you can say whether they are girls or boys, (though they do have a pink doll cradle and dolls).  I think six is about the upper end for this book though.  

Grade:  B+

I received this book free from the publisher through the BookSneeze.com book review bloggers program. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255 : “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”

Tuesday, August 03, 2010

Review: Angel's Peak

Angel's Peak (Virgin River)

I''m not sure which number this one is in the series, but it was obvious I missed quite a few books between this one and Virgin River.  This is one of those series where the author spends pages catching the reader up with characters who have little to do with the story at hand, but who the readers will remember from other stories (if they read them).

I didn't like Angel's Peak as much as I did Virgin River.  The couple in this one is Sean and Franci.  I think Sean is the brother of one of the Marine buddies of the hero of Virgin River.  He is an Air Force pilot and while he loves Franci, he doesn't want to get married or have a family.  When she insists on a commitment or a break-up, he chooses the break-up.  What she didn't tell him was the reason she drew the line in the sand, namely, she was expecting.  Fast-forward four years and they run into each other again, and he wants her back.  He soon learns about the baby and decides they should all become a family.  Franci isn't so sure....but...it's a romance novel, so guess what?

As I said before, we catch up with several couples who have gotten together in earlier books, and this book includes the wedding of one--a Presbyterian minster and a single mother.  It also features a romance between Sean's mother and the minister's father.

Why didn't I like it as much as Virgin River?  Well, for one, I prefer stories where the passion flows from the romance, rather than those where the passion leads to romance, and in this one, at least at the beginning, passion seems to be the driving force.  Also, Carr makes a big deal of Sean being raised Catholic, and his mother being uber-Catholic, but then knocks the Church's stand on birth control and has her agreeing to move in with a man without the benefit of marriage.  She also has the minister and his fiacee in bed together.  I guess I'm old fashioned and think that a minister should wait (or at least feel guilty for not waiting).

Grade:  B-

View My Stats